In the September quarter Peloton Interactive turned $559.2 million of revenue into $143.4 million of free cash flow, against capital expenditures of $2.3 million . That is the investment case stated in one line, and also the problem with it: this is a business whose capital intensity has fallen close to zero, whose cash generation is no longer in doubt, and whose customer base is shrinking at 9% a year.
Peloton sells connected bikes and treadmills and charges a monthly fee for the live and on-demand content that runs on them — about $55 a month per subscription on current revenue. It reports two segments. Connected Fitness Products, the hardware plus the Precor commercial equipment business, brought in $148.5 million in the quarter at a 33.4% gross margin; Subscription brought in $410.7 million at a 73.8% contribution margin . Subscription is the company; hardware is the acquisition channel. About 86% of revenue is American , so this is a US consumer-discretionary story with a modest international option attached.
My argument is that the market is still discounting this equity for a financing risk that was removed in the first ten days of November, and that the cash flow is durable enough to support a modestly higher price as that sinks in. What decides whether this becomes more than a modest re-rating is not earnings. It is the subscriber count Peloton reports for the December quarter.
The November 5 beat was $25 million of tariffs and recalls
The fiscal first quarter, reported November 5, looks at first glance like an inflection. Total gross margin of 61.3% came in well above the roughly 57% management had guided, Adjusted EBITDA of $167.8 million rose 42% year over year, and GAAP net income reached $96.2 million, or $0.19 a diluted share .
Strip out roughly $25 million of tariff and recall favorability and Adjusted EBITDA was $143 million — $3 million above the guidance midpoint . On the same adjustment, hardware gross margin was about 17% rather than the reported 33.4%, still a large improvement on the 6.9% of a year earlier . The operating performance was a small beat dressed as a large one, and the coincidence of the two $143 million figures is just that: one is...