Alibaba Group Holding Limited (BABA)
Locked

Alibaba Is Priced as If Its Marketplace Stalls and Its Cloud Earns Nothing

Investors are being asked to pay nothing for a compute business earning a real if unspectacular spread over its cost of capital, while a roughly RMB47 billion annual drag that management throttles with a marketing budget is treated as permanent.

Three days after reporting the fastest cloud growth it had posted in five and a half years, Alibaba went to the market for money. On August 23 it launched a placement of 710 million new shares at HK$112.70 apiece, 8.4% below the previous Hong Kong close, raising HK$80 billion — about US$10.2 billion, with all of the net proceeds earmarked for full-stack AI capability, including expanding its AI infrastructure. The Hong Kong line fell as much as 10% the following morning . A company holding more than US$30 billion of net cash had chosen to sell equity near its lows to fund a compute build, and to my reading that choice, rather than the print that preceded it, is where the de-rating began in earnest. The November leg — a chip-access scare that has taken the stock to the floor of its 52-week range — came later.

It is worth being precise about what is being funded, because Alibaba is no longer the company most investors filed away in 2021. Since the June quarter it reports in four pieces: Alibaba E-commerce Group, which folds Taobao and Tmall together with quick commerce, AliExpress and the wholesale marketplaces; AI Cloud and Compute Services, which combines Alibaba Cloud with T-Head, the in-house chip designer; AI Labs and Applications, holding the Qwen model labs, the Qwen consumer app and the QwenWork enterprise agent; and All Others, a residual containing Amap, Alibaba Health, media and games . Each segment reports on adjusted EBITA — operating income before stock compensation, intangible amortization and impairments — and that is the measure this argument uses throughout, with stock compensation charged back as a real cost wherever a valuation multiple is involved. The American depositary shares trade at about $91.41 intraday on November 16, against a 52-week range of $91.38 to $181.10 .

Start with what that price implies. The June quarter was struck on 19,324 million diluted ordinary shares, each ADS representing eight of them , and August added 710 million shares — call it 2.5 billion ADS, or roughly US$229 billion of equity value at today's quote. Management reported US$30.7 billion of net cash at June 30 ; add roughly US$10 billion of net placement proceeds, deduct the dividend paid after quarter-end, and call it US$38 billion before whatever the September quarter consumed. Alongside it sits a stake book — RMB203.2 billion of equity-method investments, mostly Ant Group, plus the non-treasury portion of a RMB431.1 billion securities portfolio (RMB88.1 billion current and...